We set out to find nut butter gifts that go beyond the obvious jar-in-a-box approach. What we've tracked down is a mix of things: some are genuine nut butter collections and variety packs from makers who've mastered their craft, others are treats and pairing sets that complement a love of nuts beautifully. Whether you're shopping for someone who spreads almond butter on toast every morning or you're after something a bit more unexpected, these are the ones that stood out.
Most arrive in formats designed for gifting—shareable tubs, letterbox-friendly kits, sets that pair nut butters with something else entirely. We've steered clear of the generic and mass-produced; these are from producers who've put genuine thought into what they're making and how it arrives at your door.
A sharing tub of handmade sweets built around celebration—perfect if you want to give something joyful without overthinking it. The variety means there's usually something for everyone at the table.
When you need something specifically for a birthday, this share tub does the job without fuss. Blue branding makes it feel intentional; the mix of sweets inside keeps it genuine.
Pinatas filled with chocolate—less about nut butters specifically, more about the sheer fun of the format. If your gift-giver knows someone who still gets excited about things that break open, this lands differently than a standard box.
A pairing that works: marshmallows infused with dark chocolate and orange, sent alongside proper tea. The combo feels grown-up, and the letterbox format means it arrives without faffing about.
Popcorn and hot chocolate together—a set that makes sense for someone who enjoys quiet nights in. Letterbox-friendly, so easy to dispatch, and it sidesteps the usual generic gift-set territory by focusing on two things that genuinely go well together.
